AAR: Operation Gaudy Terrarium


SUBMITTED:
Stardate 94765.6
FILED BY:
Captain William Levesley
SECURITY:
Level 3 - Restricted

LOCATION: Itrin System, Scavenger trading hub
MISSION: Get the Bolian trader 'Piett' to take the mission team to his supplier.
OUTCOME:
  • Contact made with 'Piett' who took part of the team to his supply location.
  • Rest of the team remained on a shadowing cloaked warbird for intervention support.
  • Teams cover identities as the crew of the Rem'lr secure. Though the 'formidable' reputation of the crew provided by Intel may not be as accurate or continue to stand up to inspection
KEY PERSONNEL:
Captain William Levesley
Captain Beylara Ailes
Captain Isadora Lyn
Captain Emery Quint
Commander Thue t'Xereth
Commander Tellara Zarath
Commander Alistair Nimitz
Sublieutenant Shiarrael t'Lhoell
Centurion Tylen
Lieutenant H'ajah

NARRATIVE:
This report consists of the inital day of the mission. A report of the following day's activities will be filed by another member of the team.

The team was assembled my selection by Fleet Intelligence services. Upon arrival Admiral Perim briefed the team on the mission objectives which were:
  • Get the trader Piett to take us to his supplies who it was hoped would be able to provide us with useful intelligence about Species 2492

The admiral made the rules of engagement clear issuing clear instructions of:
  • "You are not limited in your tactics for gaining his assistance, nor are you limited in tactics for gaining assistance of his contact, if you can get a meeting"

It is this officers opinion that when this order was given, members of the team did not quite comprehend the scope of our remit. This would later cause a contentious situation, further thoughts on which will be appended at the end of this report.

Several approaches to the target were made from the intelligence provided.
  • The targets crew was underpaid and may not be aware of the profit the trader Piett is making
  • The Itrin authorities are probably unaware of where Piett is getting his merchandise and may not be happy with being deceived by the trader
  • The trader Piett is financially supporting his extended family who live a few sectors away. - This was deemed a last resort approach as manipulating him though his family was deemed to be least likely to get an extended period of cooperation from the trader.

The team was deployed as the crew of the ship Rem'lr. The team having been made up of crew that could assume the identities of the Rem'lr's crew easily. This crew possesses, according to intelligence, a 'formidable' reputation and are known for working alone.

Upon arrival at the trader base the team spread out seeking the trader Piett, once located the team entered a cargo bay where he was overseeing his cargo alone.

At this point Lieutenant H'ajah playing the role of the Rem'lr's Captain approached and began to negotiate with the trader Piett. Unfortunately the Lts approach was rather direct concerning our interest in the traders supplier. This was in the opinion of several of the team not getting us anywhere and only proceeding to alert the target to our true intentions.

At this point I, Captain Levesley, interceded into the conversation. The rest of the team walked away leaving myself, Commander Nimitz and Commander Zarath with the trader and the cargo.
The trader assured the three of us that he got his cargo from ruins and random wreckage salvage. Commander Zarath's inspection of the cargo was that the units were age but not in a poor condition this led us to believe that the trader was lying.

I then attempted to subtly pressure the trader utilising the intelligence we received during briefing regarding his underpaid crew and the origins of his merch concerning the Itrin authorities. Both of which were either not picked up upon by the trader or were ignored. I did not want to tip our hand by mentioning the traders family so under the authority of the Admiral from the briefing applied physical pressure on the trader.

Given our crews 'reputation' I deemed the course of action appropriate. I forced the trader to the ground by pinning and manipulating his hand. After an exchange that had not yet given sufficient information. I applied further pressure after the trader told me to 'piss off'. At which point I broke the Bolians finger.

At this point several members of the team returned. Showing obvious objection to my methods. I was promptly pulled off the Bolian and the team began to act caring towards the trader. This action of sympathy may have undermined our 'formidable' reputation.

The trader was not impressed however he did state in his condition "So you can do to them what you've done to me." This implication of a 'them' should have been pursued further, as his story of finding the weapons in ruins and wreckage was falling apart. Unfortunately the team chose not to pursue that avenue of investigation.

Having been extracted from talking with the trader several of us split off from the group and attempted to converse with the traders crew elsewhere. My evaluation is that it may be feasible to insert an operative into the ships crew if necessary. However our brief encounter with them revealed little that could be utilised immediately.

At this point Captain Lyn was utilising the opportunity to speak with the trader alone. Her solo effort as a caring face, in my opinion, was successful thanks to being pushed to the other extreme by my actions. Her efforts were however exemplary given the circumstances.

After gaining Piett's trust it was arranged for members of the team to accompany him and his ship to his supplier.

This concludes my report and contains the essential information of day 1 of the operation.

RECOMMENDATION:
As a result of this mission and report I have several recommendations to make.
Firstly, that those being selected for missions are chosen by skill and experience. Not simply because they look the part. There were several members of the mission clearly lacking in experience of operating in these circumstances as well and lacking the knowledge of how such social circles as the one we were in operate.

Secondly, further time should be given over to mission preparation. The team was not given sufficient time to put in place a suitable engagement strategy that utilised all of the teams skills. The mission broke down into a series of individual efforts, that whilst achieving our objective this was not the most efficient use of those on the mission.

Thirdly, further from my first point. There are a variety of documented stratagems for infiltration, including changing the teams appearance. This I feel could have been better utilised so that the right people were given the right roles. In my opinion Lt H'ajah was out of her depth when given the role of 'Captain'.

Fourth, whilst I do not seek to criticise the preparation of this mission. In my opinion the intelligence for this mission was lacking especially concerning our crew and the way the station operates.


OOC: The report reflects my character recollection and account of the event. Unfortunately the Part 1 log posted does not contain the first section of the mission so I am unable to be detailed about the initial contact with Piett
3 Likes

SUBMITTED:
Stardate 94765.9
FILED BY:
CAPTAIN Emery Quint
SECURITY:
Level 3 - Restricted

LOCATION: Kacam
MISSION: Identify, or make contact with Piett's supplier.
OUTCOME: Success. Target identified, and possible inroads for information made.
KEY PERSONNEL:
Captain Emery Quint
Captain Isadora Lynn
Captain Beylara Ailes
Commander Alistair Nimitz
Commander Tellara Zarath

NARRATIVE: Following up on initial contact with Piett, a small team was assembled and accompanied this trader to a world designated Kacam. Upon arrival it was noted the world was a busy hub of activity and patrolled by ships of Species 2492. This along with our initial contact on the ground with a Commander Nils who identified himself as a member of the Confederacy Marines, leads me to believe this is a 2492 world.

A short conversation with Commander Nils, to explain our purpose there, yielded relevant information. It appears that in exchange for weapons from this officer, Piett brings shipments of food. Ordinarily this is imported to Kacam from 'The Ralin' but there seems to be an issue of it not getting to where it should be. At least according to the Commander. The Commander also stated that Kacam would starve without the imports from the Ralin. This gives me the impression that food items are a hot commodity in this black market.

My conversation with Commander Niles turned towards a bargain after he questioned me on not being familiar with the way things were done. Playing up some of the cover identity I explained our normal area of operations was more around Federations and Republic space. This got immediate results, as the Commander offered a deal. We provide actionable intel and he supplies us with heavy weapons from a 'Citali labs' and depending on the quality of the intel the weapons could be the latest models. Given how he spoke in reference to this lab, I assume they are a primary manufacturer of military grade weaponry. He explained he'd need to smooth things over with other officers in order to offer me anything. Once this arrangement was made we were allowed to depart, being told that given time he'd see what he could offer, and myself giving the impression I'd do the same so we could come to agreements on price.

RECOMMENDATION:
I fully recommend we assemble a brief data packet that would be similar to what a trader could document about Federation Space in a short time frame as well as something of military worth. The information in this initial packet would all have to be valid. Nothing truly endangering to the Federation or its citizens but enough to be something they could verify and feel was worth pursuing. Once this is done and we could perhaps obtain samples of their most recently developed armaments, we could then leak information in a controlled and advantageous manner to Species 2492 via this Commander.

Secondly I recommend we gain a deeper understanding of Commander Nils. Officers like him typically have two motivations for doing such things. Essentially he is either pragmatic or idealistic. If he is just making sure he and his are getting food then we have an angle to potentially make him an informant via blackmail. There is also the chance he is trying to help his people and feels that 'Good men must do bad things' as it were. If this is the case then we can appeal to this and gain his trust and TURN him. Both paths offer us opportunity to likewise gain intel on 2492's culture and military motives, but one gives us the chance to gain allies.


OOC: This was another of Kermit and Aevs funtrips. Anyone else who feels I missed something please post follow ups. I also apologize if I missed anything and will amend the report if I did so.
6 Likes

COMMAND OBSERVATION REVIEW
SUBMITTED: Stardate 94767.1


OBSERVER'S NAME: CAPT Beylara Ailes
OBSERVER ROLE: Undercover crew member
COMMANDER'S NAME: CAPT William Levesley

PERFORMANCE TRAIT
# *
SAFETY CONSCIOUSNESS
Avoided unnecessary risk of crew and equipment. Subordinates were never made to feel unsafe or concerned for their own well-being.
3.0
RESPONSIVE TO CHANGE
Adapted to changing priorities. Handled unexpected situations and does so in a calm and positive manner.
1.0
TEAMWORK AND LEADERSHIP
Overall fostered the effectiveness of others. Approachable, inclusive, and respectful. Communicated goals clearly to subordinates.
2.0
PROBLEM-SOLVING AND DECISION-MAKING
Used good judgment when evaluating a problem. Analyzed risks and identified consequences. Made appropriate decisions in a timely manner. Showed consideration for the big picture and worked towards long-term opportunities.
1.0
ROLE MODELING
Conducted self in fair and trustworthy manner. Upheld professional and ethical standards. Demonstrated and inspired subordinates to organizational values including Integrity, Compassion, and Excellence.
1.0


* Scale
1.0 Below Standards
2.0 Progressing
3.0 Meets Standards
4.0 Above Standards
5.0 Greatly Exceeds Standards



Consider the following list of qualities. If you feel you observed the Commander demonstrating any of these traits during the mission, please mark Y in the box. Comments on how this quality was demonstrated are additionally welcome.

QUALITY
OBSERVED Y/N?
FORTITUDE
Mental and emotional strength in facing difficulty, adversity, danger or temptation courageously; the strength of mind along with physical or moral courage to persevere in the face of adversity.
N
Even with the loose standards of behavior associated with the roles of the undercover mission, it is the opinion of this observer that the Captain crossed an unforgivable line by indulging in torture.
TEMPERANCE/RESPONSIBILITY
Self-discipline to control passions and appetites; being accountable, pursuing excellence, exercising self-restraint in action, statement; self-control.
N
At no point did it feel like the Captain was exercising self-restraint, repeatedly he was more interested in exerting his control as Operations Commander and interrogator than utilizing his crew effectively and preserving the roles appropriately.
PRUDENCE
Practical wisdom and the ability to make the right choice in specific situations.
N
While the observer concludes that there were multiple instances where there appeared to be poor examples of prudence (please see notes), none stand out so much as when Captain Levesley tortured his victim.
JUSTICE/FAIRNESS
Honesty, lawfulness, keeping promises; adherence to a balanced standard of justice without relevance to one’s own feelings or inclinations.
N
Captain Levesley let his poor judgment influence his decision-making, and his desire to control the situation led to him acting in a morally incomprehensible manner.
TRUSTWORTHINESS
Deserving of trust or confidence, dependable, reliable; honesty, integrity, loyalty; refraining from deception.
N/A
RESPECT
Behavior toward others; civility, courtesy, decency, dignity, autonomy, tolerance, and acceptance; the prohibition of humiliation, manipulation, and exploitation.
N/A
CARING
Honest expressions of benevolence and altruism.
N/A
CITIZENSHIP
Character and behavior in terms of the duties, obligations and values of an officer in Starfleet.
N/A




IF THERE WERE ANY DECISIONS OR ACTIONS made by the commander
that you disagree with, please state them here and why:


The very first sign that something was unsatisfactory with Captain Levelsey’s command of the situation was prior to boarding the facsimile of the scavenger ship. Lieutenant H’ajah, while getting into character, dismissed the group. Instead of having the group remain and charting a plan of action so everyone had a defined and expected course to take, he was more concerned with proving his ‘command’ and followed her dismissal with one of his own. This led to the group being fractured and disorganized on the Itrin station, and a lack of utilization of the skills and talents of the members of the mission.

The second--and in the observer’s opinion, vastly more important--decision that he failed at was during the interview-turned-interrogation of the trader/smuggler ‘Piett.’ He chose to put the victim in a painful joint-lock and followed that by breaking the man’s finger when he refused to answer the question to Captain Levesley’s satisfaction. Regardless of any undercover role the crew was expected to play, Starfleet officers are supposed to uphold certain moral values, including that of not torturing for information.

The Federation signed a binding treaty to refrain from torturing prisoners of war (I, of course, refer to the Seldonis IV Convention), and the observing officer cannot help but wonder if Captain Levesley’s morals are so muddied that he cannot grant a trader being questioned the same rights as a prisoner of war. In addition, it is a well-known fact that torture is a failure in questioning, leading only to answers the victim thinks the interrogator wants to hear, at best; hardly ever the truth.

ANY ADDITIONAL REMARKS

It appeared at several instances that Captain Levesley was trying very hard to maintain control of the situation with a rough and brutal hand that was completely unnecessary. He came close to violating the roles of the mission when he took over from the erstwhile "Captain" played by Lieutenant H'ajah. While undercover work requires some deception and bending of Starfleet and the Federation's normal high moral standard, resorting to torture is not only reprehensible, but completely ineffective (as he saw) and unnecessary.

If Captain Levesley had handled the situation from the beginning in a calm manner with effective leadership, then perhaps the crew would have had more guidance in how to perform their tasks (including Lieutenant H'ajah) and the initial meeting would not have been so jarring for the trader to put him immediately on his guard.


IF AAR HAS BEEN FILED FOR THIS MISSION, please attach:
AAR for Operation Gaudy Terrarium




END OF REVIEW.


((OOC: Thanks Kermit and Aev for the event! It was lots of fun!))
3 Likes

SUBMITTED:
Stardate 94768.4
FILED BY:
Centurion Tylen tr’Valex
SECURITY:
Level 3 - Restricted


1qAjEb9.png

LOCATION: Itrin Station
MISSION: Discover the Bolian trader Piett's supplier.
OUTCOME:
  • Contact made with Piett .
  • Negotiations resulted in Piett leading a part of the team traveling to his suppliers.
  • R.W.W. Tagor followed while cloaked to support team.
  • Cover identities remained secure as dictated by mission parameters. *See Recommendation section
KEY PERSONNEL:
Captain William Levesley
Captain Beylara Ailes
Captain Isadora Lyn
Captain Emery Quint
Commander Thue t'Xereth
Commander Tellara Zarath
Commander Alistair Nimitz
Centurion Tylen tr’Valex
Lieutenant H'ajah
Sublieutenant Shiarrael t'Lhoell

NARRATIVE:
Team members were selected by Starfleet Intelligence, due to contributed skills and coincidental resemblance to members of the Rem'lr, a salvage ship. Upon arrival, Admiral Perim began the briefing. Operational objectives included:

  • Get the trader Piett to take us to his supplies who it was hoped would be able to provide us with useful intelligence about Species 2492


Starfleet Intelligence provided several options for approaching Piett and encouraging his cooperation.
  • The targets crew was underpaid and may not be aware of the profit the trader Piett is making
  • The Itrin authorities are probably unaware of where Piett is getting his merchandise and may not be happy with being deceived by the trader
  • The trader Piett is financially supporting his extended family who live a few sectors away. - This was deemed a last resort approach as manipulating him though his family was deemed to be least likely to get an extended period of cooperation from the trader.

After receiving cover identities, the crew of the Rem’lr set course for Itrin Station. Lieutenant H’ajah, our acting Captain, had us disperse across the station in order to find where Piett conducted his business. After some time interacting with various Ferengi shop attendants, we were ordered to regroup and move to the cargo bay. Once Piett was located, Lieutenant H’ajah, Commander Zarath and Commander Nimitz approached him. With the identities assigned to the team, these three made the most sense for the approach. Myself and the others took up various positions of observation across the cargo bay.

Lieutenant H’ajah’s methods of negotiation were rather blunt and direct, as would be expected from a Klingon. Piett was immediately put on the defensive. Commander Zarath’s attempts to help were unsuccessful with the Bolian already suspicious of our motivations. It was at this point that Captain Levesley decided to intervene. The Captain had been assigned Operational Command, despite Lieutenant H’ajah’s cover assignment as the Rem’lr’s Captain. At Piett’s request, Lieutenant H’jah left Captain Levesley, Commander Zarath and Commander Nimitz to continue negotiations. After failing to utilize the information about Piett’s crew as a negotiation tool, Captain Levesley resorted to more forceful tactics. Piett was grabbed by the shoulder, forced to his knees and, when he still refused to comply, had his arm and hand forcefully twisted until Captain Levesley broke one of his fingers.

At this point, Lieutenant H’ajah returned to pull Captain Levesley off of the Bolian. A call for the Doctor, myself, was made, however Piett refused any assistance from a ‘greenskin’. Captain Lyn approached the scene and suggested the majority of the crew vacate the vicinity to allow her to attempt further negotiations. Lieutenant H’ajah gave the order. I am unable to detail Captain Lyn’s negotiations, as I was among the team members ordered to leave. Whatever she said was successful. The Bolian agreed to take several crew members of the Rem’lr with him to meet his suppliers the following day. Upon this announcement, the crew returned to Deep Space 13 for debriefing.

As a Romulan Intelligence Officer, I volunteered to be assigned to the R.W.W. Tagor to shadow the primary team. To my knowledge, Captain Levesley did not have Operational Command of the second stage of this mission. It is likely that factor alone is responsible for the success of the mission.

RECOMMENDATION:
As someone who has worked in Intelligence and under covert mission parameters, I have several recommendations to make.

Firstly, Starfleet Intelligence was unable to provide us with enough information about the roles we were to play. As I was told by the Admiral, the information they had was limited. Thus, it was up to either Starfleet Intelligence or the team itself to work out the dynamics of crew members ahead of deployment. The fact that neither Starfleet Intelligence nor the Operational Commander of the mission thought to put any time into properly establishing cover identities was a root cause of the problems that plagued our mission.

Secondly, it is clear to me that Captain Levesley is entirely unfamiliar with covert operations, interrogation methods and negotiation tactics. His attempts to utilize the information provided to us by Starfleet Intelligence were incredibly ineffective. His use of force on the Bolian also proved to be ineffective. Perhaps he could have argued he was setting up someone else to play the ‘good cop’, as humans say, but I saw no evidence of planning for this sort of tactic. In fact, Captain Levesley did not attempt to plan negotiation tactics at all. He allowed Lieutenant H’ajah to run the mission from the moment we left the debriefing room, instead of the moment we set foot on the station. Thus it is my opinion that our Operational Commander spent most of the mission attempting to regain and reassert control instead of taking control of the operation from the beginning.

Thirdly, the mission encountered a situation of too many operatives. Half of our crew could have been cut without impacting the mission. Ground crew should have comprised of the Captain, the Supercargo, the Appraiser, and Security. No others should have been required. Instead we ended up with a situation of too many people trying to approach the Bolian with different tactics. The remedy for the varying tactics is, of course, addressed in the second recommendation.

Fourthly, this mission included a Betazoid, known for their telepathic abilities. Were I operational Commander, several members of the crew would have been tasked to distract and entice the Bolian while our Betazoid remained close by and attempted to simply take the information from his head. Perhaps Captain Ailes was attempting to do just such, before Captain Levesley interrupted the negotiations. Unfortunately, because no plan of action was made before the approach was made, I was unable to discern if she was doing so or not.



OOC: Quite an interesting one to observe! Thank you Kermit and Aev for the event. If I missed anything in this report, do feel free to contact me for corrections!
2 Likes