AAR: Even When They're Winning Part 2


SUBMITTED:
Stardate 96555.7
FILED BY:
CAPT S. Bishop
SECURITY:
Level 2 - Confidential


LOCATION: Deep Space 13, Aldebaran Sector

MISSION: Interrogation of captured Xedi prisoners.

OUTCOME: Xedi prisoners interrogated successfully.

KEY PERSONNEL:
CAPT B. Ailes
CAPT S. Bishop
CAPT A. Derenzis
CAPT A. Nimitz
CAPT A. Tanaka
CMDR T. Akaela
CMDR J. T'Nar
LCDR N. Sideris
LT S. Valore

VORTA Kalris 8

NARRATIVE: Following the capture of the prisoners, they were transferred to the brig on Deep Space Thirteen. However, Captain Ailes informed us that of the prisoners we captured, only sixteen (16) remained alive; the others had killed themselves from infighting or had merely succumbed to their injuries. After it was learnt of the prisoners self culling themselves, security had separated them into their own cells.

In the briefing, Captain Ailes suggested that our questioning be directed at the answers to the following questions; where the weapons came from, why the transport was transporting cargo, what they were doing out there, and why they attacked a Starfleet vessel without provocation. This officer split the group into four teams to conduct the questioning on four individuals:

Team 1:
CAPT S. Bishop
LCDR N. Sideris
Team 2:
CAPT A. Derenzis
CMDR T. Akaela
Team 3
CAPT A. Tanaka
VORTA Kalris
Team 4
CMDR J. T'Nar
LT S. Valore

Teams 3 and 4 later joined forces after the briefing ended due to the unsuitability of prisoners to question and instead worked together in extracting information from one prisoner, bringing our total interrogations down to three.

Following the interrogations, the teams all rejoined and this officer led a debrief. A number of knowns were acertained from the interrogations, as well as a number of unknowns that would require more evidence to prove. To summarise:

The transport was transporting weapons from an unknown location (perhaps Isep Xedi itself) to the Kingdom of Parin. Given that the Xedi government did not authorise this transport, coupled with the captives' hate for the Federation, it was surmised that these captives were members of the rebel movement that has been plaguing Isep Xedi. These rebels are convinced that the Federation is propping up a tyrannical government and suppressing the religious and technological freedoms of the Xedi.

It seems that the rebel Xedi are in league with rebel faction in the Kingdom of Parin, by trading weapons and other resources between each other. These weapons are Klingon in nature, well above the technological ability of the Xedi currently. It is assumed that these weapons are being supplied by a minor Klingon house as one of the prisoners stated that they were tasked with learning about the Klingon technology her people were being supplied with, coupled with the apparent discovery of a Klingon crest found during a mission to Doza-L605 I. Whilst we cannot prove anything yet, it is not a far-fetched idea to assume that the Xedi and Parin rebel factions are potentially united over a shared hatred of the Federation.

Questioning left a number of avenues that needed to be clarified as a matter of urgency to gain a better picture of the situation and to best inform our next moves.

RECOMMENDATION: Intelligence in this area is very thin. As a matter of urgency, the following needs to be done (in no particular order).
  • Locate and identify the house on the crest that was found during the mission to Doza-L605 I. If need be, we should liaise with our KDF allies to gain this intel. This house is charged with supplying Klingon weaponry to the Xedi rebels and we must put an end to this immediately.
  • Find the Klingon weaponry on the captured ships, as well as the transport, identify what type of weaponry it is and where they are installed, and if necessary, develop counter measures to protect our ships.
  • Liaise with the government of Parin to find out who the Xedi rebels are supplying weapons to; is it the government themselves (whom we already have a treaty with), or if there is an underground rebel movement we are unaware of. If the latter, the government should be warned of this potential insurrection and the armament of the rebels.
  • A review of Federation opinion in the Doza sector and the source of the anti-Federation sentiment. There seems to be a growing concern about a misrepresentation of Federation ideals in the sector and it must be looked at immediately, especially if the actions of our officers are the cause of such sentiment.

​This officer also recommends that a permanent patrol be placed on the Isep Xedi-Parin trade route to deter any rebel shipments from taking place; this officer believes that the threat to Federation safety warrants this action, but is also tempered by the image this might portray to the residents of the sector - it could be seen as verifying the rebel's concerns about the Federation. Command and the Diplomatic Corps should carefully review the situation and come to a decision regarding this. A consultation of ship captains who patrol the region, senior command, diplomatic corps, and public relations may be beneficial in this matter.

This officer makes himself available to coordinate with DS13 Intelligence in an attempt to resolve all the holes in our intelligence thus far, at the discretion of senior command. This officer would also like to underline the importance of finding this information so that our captains are not patrolling this region of space at a disadvantage. Finally, this officer would like to reiterate the importance of captains in particular, but all members of Starfleet, of maintaining a fair and positive image of the Federation at all times; we cannot give more public relations ammunition to the Xedi rebels who do not need any more convincing that the Federation is an authoritarian police force designed to suffocate the progress on any race who are not part of their membership.



OOC: This is Sam's report on the briefing and debriefing of the Xedi interrogations. It would be good if someone is able to follow up on these recommendations; I'm happy to have Sam take lead if needed.
4 Likes

SUBMITTED:
Stardate 96555.7
FILED BY:
CAPT S. Bishop
SECURITY:
Level 3 - Restricted


ADDENDUM: Following a notice from one of the officers during the interrogations, this officer would like a review of the actions of Captain Tanaka, Commander T'Nar, Lieutenant Valore, and Vorta Kalris during their interrogation of the Xedi prisoner, more specifically regarding an accusation that Captain Tanaka was close to torturing the Xedi prisoner but was stopped, despite a warning from this officer at the start of the interrogations to perform said interrogations with the rights given to any prisoner of the Federation.

Should the Captain be found to have been close to torturing the prisoner, serious action must be levied, as this type of behaviour flies in the face of our oaths as Starfleet Officers. There is no circumstance where torture, or even the threat of torture, is acceptable. Actions such as these only fuels the anti-Federation sentiment that was outlined in the above report.

The prisoner in question should also be given immediate medical and psychological assistance to combat any trauma they might have suffered because of this.
8 Likes

SUBMITTED:
Stardate 96555.4
FILED BY:
LT S. Valore
SECURITY:
Level 3 - Restricted


ADDENDUM: This officer intends this report to focus primarily on the interrogation she participated in. We arrived to find the prisoner to be in the midst of crying. Kalris suggested utilizing Dominion lie detector equipment, but required a baseline. Commander T'Nar was carrying a large watercooler but refused to state what it was he intended, instead saying it was for the interrogation. Captain Tanaka directed me to calm down the prisoner for the next round of interrogation.

This officer proceeded in an attempt to converse with the prisoner. After several questions related to well-being of the prisoner, along with other personal questions such as their name and occupation, the prisoner began to open up. They informed this officer that her duty was understanding the Klingon technology her faction had received aboard their vessel.

This officer returned to the others, informing them that I believe the prisoner to be very compliant with the Federation. This officer recommended making a request to have the prisoner be brought from a cell to house arrest in a quarters as a means to reward the compliance and elicit more of it. Captain Tanaka objected to the matter, claiming that he believed such an act to be considered the granting of amnesty to a potentially dangerous individual. The Dominion representative, Kalris, decided to pursue my recommendation.

She went to the cell, introducing herself to the prisoner. She began explaining the basics of the Dominion and its relationship to the Federation, and the prisoner's cooperation with the authorities. There was some conversation on the Xedi in general, but this officer was focused upon an interaction with Captain Tanaka in which this officer attempted to provide scenarios that could allow the Captain to pursue the logical framework for why an individual would attempt to act against their government.

Upon the return of the Dominion representative, Captain Tanaka had chosen to take it upon himself to interrogate the prisoner. He instructed the computer to provide audio and visual sensations to the Xedi when he gave cues that would be very distressing and could be considered torture by some. The Dominion representative referred to it as Dominion Advanced Interrogation Techniques. Commander T'Nar and I immediately objected to the matter. This officer had considered calling Captain Bishop, but believed that the matter could be solved without escalating it further. This officer spoke to the Commander and informed him that we would be duty-bound to remove and neutralize Captain Tanaka from the interrogation room. At this point, Captain Tanaka was attempting to verbally inform us from the interrogation room that he did not intend to harm the prisoner - yet he took every step to ensure he would, in fact, cause harm to them.

Before the Commander and I could intervene, the Captain chose instead to depart the interrogation room without beginning, informing us that he did not intend for us 'to become monsters today'. He also informed this officer to report him if she felt that his actions deemed it necessary. After a conference with Captain Bishop following the debrief, this officer believes it now to be necessary.

A matter that was discussed at the debriefing was that the Federation is not the authoritarian secret police of the Doza sector that props up what the rebels perceive to be tyrannical governments. Captain Tanaka's actions contradict this.
6 Likes